What happens if I let the hag live in Baldur's Gate 3?

In Baldur's Gate 3, the encounter with the hag, Auntie Ethel, is a pivotal moment in Act 1 that presents players with a moral dilemma and significant story consequences. The hag is found in the Sunlit Wetlands, which is actually a disguised version of the Putrid Bog. She is holding a young woman named Mayrina captive, and the player must decide whether to confront her or negotiate. One of the key choices is whether to let the hag live or kill her. Letting the hag live has several implications for the story, character relationships, and future quests.

To let the hag live, you must first engage in combat with her. The fight takes place in her lair, which is filled with traps, illusions, and environmental hazards. The hag is a formidable opponent with abilities like invisibility, teleportation, and powerful spells. She can also summon copies of herself to confuse and distract the player. The combat is challenging, but it is possible to defeat her without killing her. When her health drops below a certain threshold, she will offer a deal to spare her life in exchange for a reward. This is the moment where you can choose to let her live.

The mechanics of this choice involve dialogue options and combat tactics. During the fight, you need to be careful not to deal too much damage to the hag at once, as this could kill her before she has a chance to offer the deal. It is important to manage your party's actions and use non-lethal attacks if possible. When the hag's health is low, she will initiate a dialogue where she offers to give you a powerful item, such as the Hag's Hair, in exchange for her life. You can accept this deal, and she will teleport away, leaving you with the reward.

There are several important tips and considerations to keep in mind when deciding to let the hag live. First, the reward you receive can be very useful, but it comes at a cost. The Hag's Hair, for example, grants a permanent +1 bonus to an ability score of your choice, but it also has a dark side effect that can influence your character's behavior. Additionally, letting the hag live means that she will continue to cause trouble in the world, potentially leading to negative consequences later in the game. You should weigh the benefits of the reward against the potential long-term impact on the story and your character's morality.

Common mistakes to avoid include accidentally killing the hag before she can offer the deal, or failing to manage your party's actions effectively during the fight. It is important to pay attention to the hag's health and adjust your strategy accordingly. Using spells and abilities that deal non-lethal damage can help ensure that she survives long enough to make the offer. Additionally, be prepared for the hag's tricks and illusions, as they can make the fight more difficult if you are not careful.

Advanced techniques and optimizations for this encounter involve careful planning and coordination with your party. For example, you can use spells like Hold Person or Sleep to incapacitate the hag and prevent her from using her abilities. You can also use environmental hazards to your advantage, such as pushing her into traps or using the terrain to limit her movement. It is also helpful to have a character with high Perception to detect and disarm traps in the lair, as this can make the fight easier.

In terms of related D&D rules and mechanics, the hag's abilities are based on the 5th Edition rules for hags, which include traits like invisibility, teleportation, and spellcasting. The combat encounter is designed to challenge players and encourage creative problem-solving. The choice to let the hag live or kill her is a reflection of the game's emphasis on moral dilemmas and the consequences of player actions.

Specific examples and scenarios include the potential impact on Mayrina's story. If you let the hag live, Mayrina will be left in a difficult situation, as the hag will continue to manipulate and control her. This can lead to further quests and interactions with Mayrina later in the game. Additionally, the hag's continued presence in the world can influence other storylines and character relationships, making this choice a significant one in the overall narrative.

In conclusion, letting the hag live in Baldur's Gate 3 is a complex decision with both immediate and long-term consequences. It requires careful planning and strategy during the combat encounter, as well as a thoughtful consideration of the moral and narrative implications. By understanding the mechanics, avoiding common mistakes, and using advanced techniques, you can make an informed choice that aligns with your character's goals and values.