What happens if I let the Emperor control the Netherbrain in Act 2 of Baldur's Gate 3?

In Baldur's Gate 3, the Emperor is a key figure tied to the Mind Flayer colony and the Netherbrain, a powerful entity that plays a central role in the game's story. Allowing the Emperor to control the Netherbrain is a significant decision that can drastically alter the course of the narrative, particularly in Act 2. This choice is deeply tied to the game's themes of power, control, and morality, and it requires careful consideration of the consequences.

To let the Emperor control the Netherbrain, you must first progress through the main story until you reach the point where the Emperor reveals his true nature and intentions. This typically occurs during the latter part of Act 2, when you are deep within the Mind Flayer colony. The Emperor will present you with a choice: either allow him to take control of the Netherbrain or resist his influence and seek another solution. Choosing to let the Emperor control the Netherbrain involves a series of dialogue options and decisions that align with his goals.

The mechanics of this choice revolve around your interactions with the Emperor and your ability to navigate the complex moral and strategic implications of his plan. The Emperor will attempt to persuade you that controlling the Netherbrain is the only way to prevent a greater catastrophe, and he will use his psychic abilities to influence your decisions. To proceed with this path, you must consistently choose dialogue options that show trust in the Emperor and a willingness to embrace his vision. This may involve siding with him in key moments, such as when he confronts other characters who oppose his methods.

One important tip is to ensure that your character has a high Charisma score or proficiency in Persuasion, as this will make it easier to navigate the dialogue and maintain a positive relationship with the Emperor. Additionally, consider the alignment and motivations of your character. A character who values pragmatism and the greater good may be more inclined to support the Emperor, while a character with a strong moral compass may find this choice more difficult to justify.

A common mistake to avoid is underestimating the long-term consequences of this decision. Allowing the Emperor to control the Netherbrain may seem like a quick solution to the immediate threat, but it can lead to unforeseen complications later in the story. For example, other characters, including your companions, may react negatively to your choice, potentially leading to conflicts or even their departure from your party. It is also important to consider how this decision aligns with your overall goals and the type of ending you want to achieve.

Advanced techniques for this path include exploring alternative dialogue options that allow you to subtly manipulate the Emperor while still appearing to support his plans. This can give you more control over the outcome and potentially mitigate some of the negative consequences. Additionally, consider the role of your companions in this decision. Some companions, such as Lae'zel or Shadowheart, may have strong opinions about the Emperor and his methods, and their reactions can influence the overall dynamic of your party.

From a D&D rules perspective, the Emperor's ability to control the Netherbrain is rooted in the Mind Flayer's innate psychic powers and their connection to the Illithid hive mind. In the context of the game, this translates to a narrative-driven mechanic where your choices determine the balance of power between the Emperor and the Netherbrain. The game's implementation of these rules allows for a high degree of player agency, enabling you to shape the story in meaningful ways.

Specific examples of this choice in action include moments where the Emperor may ask you to make sacrifices or take actions that seem morally questionable. For instance, he might request that you eliminate a rival faction or betray an ally to secure his control over the Netherbrain. These scenarios test your character's resolve and force you to weigh the immediate benefits against the long-term implications.

In summary, allowing the Emperor to control the Netherbrain in Act 2 of Baldur's Gate 3 is a complex and impactful decision that requires careful consideration of the narrative, your character's alignment, and the potential consequences. By understanding the mechanics involved, making strategic dialogue choices, and considering the reactions of your companions, you can navigate this path effectively and shape the story in a way that aligns with your vision for the game.