What happens if I let the Emperor kill Orpheus in Baldur's Gate 3?

In Baldur's Gate 3, the decision to let the Emperor kill Orpheus is a pivotal moment in the game's story, with significant consequences for the narrative and the fate of key characters. This choice occurs during the late stages of the game, specifically in Act 3, when the player is faced with the dilemma of whether to side with the Emperor, a mind flayer who has been guiding the party, or to free Orpheus, a powerful githyanki prince who has been imprisoned by the mind flayers. The decision to let the Emperor kill Orpheus is a morally complex one, and it has far-reaching implications for the story and the player's relationships with their companions.

To achieve this outcome, the player must first progress through the main story until they reach the point where they are confronted with the choice between siding with the Emperor or freeing Orpheus. This occurs after the player has gathered the necessary allies and resources to confront the Absolute, the game's primary antagonist. The Emperor will present the player with a choice: either allow him to consume Orpheus's mind, which will grant the Emperor the power needed to defeat the Absolute, or free Orpheus and risk losing the Emperor's support.

The mechanics involved in this decision are primarily narrative-driven, meaning that the player's choice will directly influence the outcome of the story. There are no specific combat mechanics or skill checks required to make this decision, but the player's previous choices and relationships with their companions will play a significant role in how the story unfolds. For example, if the player has built a strong relationship with Lae'zel, a githyanki companion who is deeply invested in freeing Orpheus, they may face additional challenges in convincing her to accept the Emperor's decision to kill Orpheus.

To let the Emperor kill Orpheus, the player must choose to side with the Emperor when presented with the choice. This decision will lead to a cutscene in which the Emperor consumes Orpheus's mind, gaining the power needed to confront the Absolute. The player will then proceed to the final stages of the game, where they will face the Absolute in a climactic battle. The outcome of this battle will depend on the player's choices throughout the game, including their decision to let the Emperor kill Orpheus.

Important tips and considerations for this decision include the potential impact on the player's relationships with their companions. Lae'zel, in particular, will be deeply affected by the decision to kill Orpheus, as she sees him as a savior figure for the githyanki people. If the player has built a strong relationship with Lae'zel, they may need to carefully navigate the conversation with her to avoid alienating her or causing her to leave the party. Additionally, the player should consider the broader implications of their decision, as siding with the Emperor may lead to a more morally ambiguous ending, while freeing Orpheus could result in a more heroic conclusion.

Common mistakes to avoid include making this decision without considering the long-term consequences. The choice to let the Emperor kill Orpheus is irreversible, and it will have a significant impact on the game's ending. Players should take the time to weigh their options and consider how their decision will affect their companions and the overall story. Additionally, players should avoid making this decision based solely on the immediate benefits, as the long-term consequences may outweigh any short-term gains.

Advanced techniques or optimizations for this decision include leveraging the player's relationships with their companions to influence the outcome. For example, if the player has built a strong relationship with the Emperor, they may be able to convince him to spare Orpheus or find a compromise that allows both characters to survive. Similarly, if the player has built a strong relationship with Lae'zel, they may be able to persuade her to accept the Emperor's decision, even if it goes against her beliefs.

Related D&D rules and mechanics include the concept of moral alignment and the impact of player choices on the story. In Dungeons & Dragons, a character's alignment reflects their moral and ethical outlook, and this can influence their decisions and interactions with other characters. In Baldur's Gate 3, the player's choices, including the decision to let the Emperor kill Orpheus, will reflect their character's alignment and shape the story accordingly.

Specific examples and scenarios include the potential for the player to face a moral dilemma if they have built strong relationships with both the Emperor and Lae'zel. In this case, the player may need to carefully navigate the conversation with both characters to avoid alienating either one. Additionally, the player may encounter different outcomes depending on their previous choices, such as whether they have allied with the githyanki or the mind flayers earlier in the game.

In conclusion, the decision to let the Emperor kill Orpheus in Baldur's Gate 3 is a complex and morally challenging choice that will have significant consequences for the story and the player's relationships with their companions. Players should carefully consider the long-term implications of this decision and take the time to weigh their options before making a final choice. By leveraging their relationships with their companions and considering the broader narrative implications, players can navigate this decision and shape the story in a way that aligns with their character's moral and ethical outlook.