What are the consequences of letting the Githyanki kill Orpheus in Baldur's Gate 3?

Letting the Githyanki kill Orpheus in Baldur's Gate 3 is a significant story choice that has far-reaching consequences for the game's narrative, particularly in the late stages of the campaign. Orpheus is a central figure in the Githyanki lore, and his fate is tied to the broader conflict involving the Mind Flayers, the Githyanki, and the player's journey to rid themselves of the Illithid tadpole. HereÔÇÖs a detailed breakdown of what happens if you allow the Githyanki to kill Orpheus, along with the mechanics, strategies, and considerations involved.

To let the Githyanki kill Orpheus, you must first reach the late stages of the game, specifically the point where you confront the Elder Brain and the Githyanki leadership. Orpheus is imprisoned in the Astral Prism, and his fate becomes a pivotal decision. If you side with the Githyanki, particularly Vlaakith or her loyalists, they will demand Orpheus's death. This decision is not made lightly, as it affects your relationship with Lae'zel, the Githyanki companion, and the overall outcome of the story.

The mechanics of this choice involve dialogue and alignment with the Githyanki. When you reach the Astral Prism, you will have the option to either free Orpheus or allow the Githyanki to kill him. If you choose the latter, you must align with Vlaakith's forces, which means rejecting Orpheus's potential to help you against the Mind Flayers. This decision locks you into a path where the Githyanki become your primary allies, but it also means you lose the opportunity to use Orpheus's powers to resist the Illithid influence.

Step-by-step, hereÔÇÖs how this plays out. First, you must progress through the main questline until you reach the Astral Prism. This occurs after the events of Act 2 and into Act 3. Once there, you will encounter the Githyanki leadership, who will present you with the choice to kill Orpheus. If you agree, Vlaakith's forces will execute him, and you will gain their support. However, this decision will alienate Lae'zel if she is in your party, as she is deeply loyal to Orpheus and his cause. Lae'zel may leave your party or even turn against you, depending on your previous interactions with her.

Important tips and considerations include understanding the long-term consequences of this choice. Killing Orpheus means you lose a powerful ally against the Mind Flayers, and you must rely on the Githyanki for support. This can make the final battles more challenging, as you will not have Orpheus's abilities to aid you. Additionally, this choice affects the ending of the game, as it determines the fate of the Githyanki people and their struggle for freedom from Vlaakith's tyranny.

Common mistakes to avoid include making this decision without considering the impact on your party dynamics. If Lae'zel is a key member of your team, her departure can significantly weaken your group. ItÔÇÖs also important to weigh the moral implications of siding with Vlaakith, as she is a ruthless and power-hungry leader who may not have your best interests at heart.

Advanced techniques or optimizations involve preparing your party for the loss of Orpheus's support. This might include building up your characters' abilities to compensate for the lack of his powers. For example, focusing on strong melee fighters or spellcasters who can handle the increased difficulty of the final battles. Additionally, you can explore alternative strategies for dealing with the Mind Flayers, such as using items or abilities that provide resistance to their psychic attacks.

Related D&D rules and mechanics come into play with the concept of alignment and faction loyalty. In D&D, alignment reflects a character's moral and ethical stance, and siding with Vlaakith may shift your character's alignment towards lawful evil. This can affect how NPCs interact with you and the types of quests available. Faction loyalty is also a key mechanic, as your choice to align with the Githyanki will open up new opportunities but close off others.

Specific examples and scenarios include the final confrontation with the Elder Brain. Without Orpheus's help, you may need to rely on other means to resist the Illithid influence, such as using the Astral Prism's remaining powers or finding alternative allies. The ending of the game will also reflect your choice, with the Githyanki either continuing under Vlaakith's rule or potentially finding a new path if Orpheus had been freed.

In summary, letting the Githyanki kill Orpheus is a major decision that affects the story, your party, and the game's ending. It requires careful consideration of the consequences and preparation for the challenges ahead. By understanding the mechanics and implications of this choice, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your character's goals and the story you want to experience.