What happens if I let the Emperor consume Orpheus in Baldur's Gate 3?

In Baldur's Gate 3, the decision to let the Emperor consume Orpheus is a pivotal moment in the game's story, with significant consequences for the narrative and the characters involved. This choice occurs during the late stages of the game, specifically in Act 3, when the player is faced with the dilemma of how to deal with the Illithid threat and the fate of Orpheus, a powerful Githyanki prince who has been imprisoned by the Mind Flayers. The Emperor, a Mind Flayer who has been guiding the player throughout the game, presents this option as a way to gain the power needed to defeat the Absolute, the game's primary antagonist. However, this choice is not without its moral and strategic implications.

To reach this decision point, the player must progress through the main story quests, particularly those involving the Githyanki and the Mind Flayers. The player will encounter Orpheus in the Astral Plane, where he is being held captive. The Emperor will reveal his true nature as a Mind Flayer and offer the player the choice to either free Orpheus or allow the Emperor to consume him. If the player chooses to let the Emperor consume Orpheus, the Emperor will gain immense power, which he claims is necessary to defeat the Absolute. However, this choice will have significant consequences for the player's relationship with the Githyanki, particularly with Lae'zel, a Githyanki companion who is deeply invested in freeing Orpheus.

The mechanics of this choice are relatively straightforward, but the implications are complex. When the player chooses to let the Emperor consume Orpheus, the Emperor will absorb Orpheus's essence, gaining his powers and becoming even more formidable. This will immediately alter the dynamics of the story, as the Githyanki will view the player as an enemy for allowing their prince to be consumed. Lae'zel, in particular, will be deeply affected by this decision, and her loyalty to the player will be severely tested. Depending on the player's previous interactions with Lae'zel, she may even leave the party or turn against the player.

One important tip to consider is the impact this choice will have on the player's overall strategy. Allowing the Emperor to consume Orpheus will grant the player a powerful ally in the final battles against the Absolute, but it will also alienate the Githyanki, who could have been valuable allies in the fight. Players should weigh the benefits of having a more powerful Emperor against the potential loss of Githyanki support. Additionally, players should consider the moral implications of this choice, as it involves sacrificing a potentially innocent and powerful being for the sake of gaining power.

A common mistake to avoid is making this decision without fully understanding the consequences. Players should take the time to explore all available dialogue options and gather as much information as possible before making this choice. It is also important to consider the player's relationship with Lae'zel and the Githyanki, as this decision will have a lasting impact on those relationships. Players who are invested in Lae'zel's personal questline may want to think carefully before allowing the Emperor to consume Orpheus, as it could lead to a breakdown in their relationship.

Advanced techniques for optimizing this choice involve considering the player's overall build and strategy. For example, players who have focused on building a strong relationship with the Emperor may find that allowing him to consume Orpheus aligns with their goals, as it will make him a more powerful ally in the final battles. On the other hand, players who have invested in building a strong relationship with Lae'zel and the Githyanki may want to consider alternative options, such as freeing Orpheus and finding another way to defeat the Absolute.

In terms of D&D rules and mechanics, this choice reflects the game's emphasis on moral dilemmas and the consequences of player actions. The decision to allow the Emperor to consume Orpheus is a classic example of a morally ambiguous choice, where the player must weigh the potential benefits against the ethical implications. This choice also highlights the importance of understanding the motivations and goals of the characters involved, as well as the potential impact on the player's relationships with those characters.

Specific examples and scenarios can help illustrate the consequences of this choice. For instance, if the player allows the Emperor to consume Orpheus, they may find themselves facing a more difficult final battle, as the Githyanki will no longer be willing to assist. On the other hand, players who choose to free Orpheus may find that they have a powerful ally in the final battle, but they will also have to contend with the Emperor's potential betrayal. Ultimately, the choice to let the Emperor consume Orpheus is a complex and impactful decision that will shape the player's experience of the game's story and ending.