What happens if I let the Emperor consume Orpheus in Baldur's Gate 3?

In Baldur's Gate 3, the decision to let the Emperor consume Orpheus is a pivotal moment in the game's story, with significant consequences for the narrative and the characters involved. This choice occurs during the late stages of the game, specifically in Act 3, when the player is faced with the dilemma of how to deal with the Mind Flayer threat and the fate of Orpheus, a powerful Githyanki prince who has been imprisoned by the Mind Flayers. The Emperor, a Mind Flayer who has been guiding the player throughout the game, presents this option as a way to gain the power needed to defeat the Absolute, the game's primary antagonist.

To reach this decision point, the player must progress through the main story quests, particularly those involving the Githyanki and the Mind Flayers. This includes completing quests such as "The Githyanki Creche" and "The Astral Prism," which provide crucial context about Orpheus and his importance to the Githyanki people. As the story unfolds, the player will learn more about the Emperor's true nature and his connection to Orpheus. The Emperor reveals that consuming Orpheus will grant him the power necessary to confront the Absolute, but it will also result in the death of Orpheus, a figure revered by the Githyanki.

When the moment of decision arrives, the player is presented with a choice: allow the Emperor to consume Orpheus or find another way to deal with the threat. If the player chooses to let the Emperor consume Orpheus, the following steps and considerations come into play. First, the player must ensure that they have built a strong relationship with the Emperor throughout the game. This involves making choices that align with the Emperor's goals and showing trust in his guidance. A high level of trust with the Emperor increases the likelihood that he will successfully consume Orpheus and gain the necessary power.

Once the decision is made, the Emperor will proceed to consume Orpheus, resulting in a significant shift in the story. The Emperor gains immense power, which he uses to aid the player in the final battle against the Absolute. However, this choice also has major consequences for the Githyanki and their quest for freedom. Orpheus's death means that the Githyanki lose their chance to free themselves from Vlaakith's tyranny, and the player's relationship with Lae'zel, a Githyanki companion, will be severely impacted. Lae'zel may turn against the player, viewing the decision as a betrayal of her people and their cause.

There are several important tips and considerations to keep in mind when making this choice. First, players should carefully weigh the moral implications of allowing the Emperor to consume Orpheus. While it may provide a powerful ally in the final battle, it also means sacrificing a key figure in the Githyanki's struggle for freedom. Additionally, players should consider the impact on their relationships with companions, particularly Lae'zel, who may leave the party or become hostile if Orpheus is consumed.

Common mistakes to avoid include making this decision without fully understanding the consequences. Players should take the time to explore all available dialogue options and gather as much information as possible about Orpheus and the Emperor before making a choice. Rushing into the decision without considering the long-term effects on the story and relationships can lead to unintended outcomes.

Advanced techniques and optimizations involve leveraging the player's knowledge of the game's mechanics and story to make the most informed decision possible. This includes using high Charisma and Persuasion skills to influence the Emperor and other characters, as well as exploring alternative solutions to the Mind Flayer threat. For example, players may choose to side with Orpheus and find another way to defeat the Absolute, preserving the Githyanki's hope for freedom.

In terms of related D&D rules and mechanics, the decision to let the Emperor consume Orpheus reflects the game's emphasis on moral dilemmas and the consequences of player choices. The alignment system, which tracks the player's moral and ethical decisions, plays a significant role in shaping the story and relationships. Allowing the Emperor to consume Orpheus may align the player with a more utilitarian or pragmatic approach, prioritizing the greater good over individual lives.

Specific examples and scenarios include interactions with Lae'zel and other Githyanki characters, who may react strongly to the player's decision. For instance, if the player has built a strong bond with Lae'zel, her reaction to Orpheus's death may be particularly emotional and impactful. Conversely, if the player has a strained relationship with Lae'zel, her departure or hostility may be less surprising but still significant.

In conclusion, the decision to let the Emperor consume Orpheus in Baldur's Gate 3 is a complex and consequential choice that requires careful consideration of the game's story, mechanics, and relationships. By understanding the implications and exploring all available options, players can make an informed decision that aligns with their desired outcomes and playstyle.