What are the consequences of letting Ethel live in Baldur's Gate 3?
Letting Ethel live in Baldur's Gate 3 is a significant story choice that occurs during the quest "Save Mayrina." Ethel, also known as Auntie Ethel, is a hag who has kidnapped Mayrina, a pregnant woman, and is holding her captive in her lair. The consequences of letting Ethel live are multifaceted and can impact the story, your companions, and the world around you. Here is a detailed explanation of the mechanics, strategies, and considerations involved in making this choice.
When you confront Ethel in her lair, you have the option to fight her or negotiate with her. If you choose to negotiate, you can strike a deal where she releases Mayrina in exchange for her life. This decision has several immediate and long-term consequences. First, Ethel will give you a reward, which is typically a powerful item or ability. For example, she might offer you the "Hag's Hair," which grants a permanent +1 boost to one of your ability scores. This is a significant boon, as ability score improvements are rare and valuable in the game.
However, letting Ethel live also means that she will continue to exist in the world, potentially causing more harm. Hags are known for their malevolent nature, and Ethel is no exception. By sparing her, you are allowing her to continue her schemes, which could lead to further suffering for others. This moral dilemma is a key aspect of the choice, as it forces you to weigh the immediate benefits against the potential long-term consequences.
In terms of mechanics, the negotiation with Ethel involves a series of dialogue checks. You will need to pass Persuasion, Intimidation, or Deception checks to successfully convince her to release Mayrina and spare her life. These checks can be challenging, so it is important to have a character with high Charisma and proficiency in the relevant skills. If you fail these checks, Ethel may become hostile, forcing you into combat.
One strategy to improve your chances of success is to prepare before entering the lair. Ensure that your party is well-rested and has all necessary buffs and spells active. You can also use items that boost your Charisma or provide advantage on skill checks. Additionally, having a character with the "Guidance" cantrip can provide a helpful bonus to your rolls.
A common mistake to avoid is underestimating Ethel's cunning. She is a master manipulator and will try to deceive you at every turn. Be cautious of her offers and promises, as they may come with hidden strings attached. For example, she might offer to help you in the future, but her assistance could come at a great cost.
Advanced techniques involve leveraging your knowledge of Ethel's weaknesses and motivations. Hags are often driven by self-interest, so appealing to her desire for self-preservation can be effective. You can also use your knowledge of her lair to your advantage. For instance, if you have explored the area thoroughly, you might discover hidden traps or environmental hazards that can be used against her.
From a D&D rules perspective, hags are powerful fey creatures with a variety of magical abilities. They are known for their ability to shape-shift, cast illusions, and manipulate others. Understanding these abilities can help you anticipate her actions and respond accordingly. For example, if you know that Ethel can turn invisible, you can prepare spells or abilities that reveal hidden creatures.
Specific examples of the consequences of letting Ethel live include potential future encounters with her. She may appear later in the game, either as an ally or an enemy, depending on your choices. Additionally, the fate of Mayrina and her unborn child can be influenced by your decision. If you let Ethel live, Mayrina may be left in a precarious situation, as Ethel's influence over her could continue.
In summary, letting Ethel live in Baldur's Gate 3 is a complex decision with both immediate rewards and long-term consequences. It involves careful negotiation, strategic preparation, and a deep understanding of the game's mechanics and story. By considering the moral implications, leveraging your character's strengths, and anticipating Ethel's actions, you can make an informed choice that aligns with your playstyle and goals.
When you confront Ethel in her lair, you have the option to fight her or negotiate with her. If you choose to negotiate, you can strike a deal where she releases Mayrina in exchange for her life. This decision has several immediate and long-term consequences. First, Ethel will give you a reward, which is typically a powerful item or ability. For example, she might offer you the "Hag's Hair," which grants a permanent +1 boost to one of your ability scores. This is a significant boon, as ability score improvements are rare and valuable in the game.
However, letting Ethel live also means that she will continue to exist in the world, potentially causing more harm. Hags are known for their malevolent nature, and Ethel is no exception. By sparing her, you are allowing her to continue her schemes, which could lead to further suffering for others. This moral dilemma is a key aspect of the choice, as it forces you to weigh the immediate benefits against the potential long-term consequences.
In terms of mechanics, the negotiation with Ethel involves a series of dialogue checks. You will need to pass Persuasion, Intimidation, or Deception checks to successfully convince her to release Mayrina and spare her life. These checks can be challenging, so it is important to have a character with high Charisma and proficiency in the relevant skills. If you fail these checks, Ethel may become hostile, forcing you into combat.
One strategy to improve your chances of success is to prepare before entering the lair. Ensure that your party is well-rested and has all necessary buffs and spells active. You can also use items that boost your Charisma or provide advantage on skill checks. Additionally, having a character with the "Guidance" cantrip can provide a helpful bonus to your rolls.
A common mistake to avoid is underestimating Ethel's cunning. She is a master manipulator and will try to deceive you at every turn. Be cautious of her offers and promises, as they may come with hidden strings attached. For example, she might offer to help you in the future, but her assistance could come at a great cost.
Advanced techniques involve leveraging your knowledge of Ethel's weaknesses and motivations. Hags are often driven by self-interest, so appealing to her desire for self-preservation can be effective. You can also use your knowledge of her lair to your advantage. For instance, if you have explored the area thoroughly, you might discover hidden traps or environmental hazards that can be used against her.
From a D&D rules perspective, hags are powerful fey creatures with a variety of magical abilities. They are known for their ability to shape-shift, cast illusions, and manipulate others. Understanding these abilities can help you anticipate her actions and respond accordingly. For example, if you know that Ethel can turn invisible, you can prepare spells or abilities that reveal hidden creatures.
Specific examples of the consequences of letting Ethel live include potential future encounters with her. She may appear later in the game, either as an ally or an enemy, depending on your choices. Additionally, the fate of Mayrina and her unborn child can be influenced by your decision. If you let Ethel live, Mayrina may be left in a precarious situation, as Ethel's influence over her could continue.
In summary, letting Ethel live in Baldur's Gate 3 is a complex decision with both immediate rewards and long-term consequences. It involves careful negotiation, strategic preparation, and a deep understanding of the game's mechanics and story. By considering the moral implications, leveraging your character's strengths, and anticipating Ethel's actions, you can make an informed choice that aligns with your playstyle and goals.