What are the consequences of letting the Emperor consume Orpheus in Baldur's Gate 3?

In Baldur's Gate 3, the decision to let the Emperor consume Orpheus is a pivotal moment in the game's story, with significant consequences for the narrative, your companions, and the world at large. This choice occurs during the late stages of the game, specifically in Act 3, when you are dealing with the threat of the Absolute and the Mind Flayer invasion. The Emperor, a Mind Flayer who has been guiding you throughout the game, presents you with a difficult choice: allow him to consume Orpheus, the Githyanki prince, to gain the power needed to defeat the Absolute, or refuse and seek an alternative path.

To understand the mechanics and consequences of this choice, it's important to first grasp the context. Orpheus is a key figure in Githyanki lore, imprisoned by the Mind Flayers for centuries. His power is tied to the Githyanki's ability to resist Mind Flayer influence, and freeing him could potentially turn the tide against the Absolute. However, the Emperor argues that consuming Orpheus is the only way to harness the necessary power to defeat the Absolute, as Orpheus's abilities are uniquely suited to countering Mind Flayer domination.

If you choose to let the Emperor consume Orpheus, several consequences unfold. First, the Emperor gains immense power, which he uses to help you in the final battle against the Absolute. This can make the final confrontation easier, as the Emperor's enhanced abilities can turn the tide in your favor. However, this choice comes at a cost. Consuming Orpheus means that the Githyanki lose their prince, and their hope for liberation from Mind Flayer influence is dashed. This can have long-term consequences for the Githyanki people, potentially leading to further conflict and instability in their society.

Additionally, this choice affects your relationship with Lae'zel, the Githyanki companion in your party. Lae'zel is deeply committed to freeing Orpheus and sees him as the key to her people's future. If you allow the Emperor to consume Orpheus, Lae'zel will be devastated and may turn against you, depending on your previous interactions with her. This can lead to her leaving the party or even becoming hostile, which can significantly impact your final battle and the overall story.

From a gameplay perspective, allowing the Emperor to consume Orpheus can simplify the final battle, as the Emperor's enhanced powers can provide significant advantages. However, it also closes off certain story paths and character arcs, particularly those related to the Githyanki and Lae'zel. If you are invested in the Githyanki storyline or want to maintain a positive relationship with Lae'zel, this choice may not be the best option.

One important tip is to consider your party composition and your overall goals before making this decision. If you have a strong connection with Lae'zel and want to see her story arc through to a positive conclusion, you may want to explore alternative options, such as finding a way to free Orpheus without sacrificing him. This can involve making different choices earlier in the game, such as aligning with certain factions or gathering specific resources that can be used to counter the Emperor's plan.

Another consideration is the moral implications of your choice. Allowing the Emperor to consume Orpheus can be seen as a pragmatic decision, as it provides a clear path to defeating the Absolute. However, it also involves sacrificing a key figure who represents hope for an entire race. This moral dilemma is a central theme in Baldur's Gate 3, and your choice will reflect your character's values and priorities.

In terms of D&D rules and mechanics, the decision to let the Emperor consume Orpheus ties into the broader themes of power, sacrifice, and the consequences of one's actions. In Dungeons and Dragons, choices like these often have far-reaching implications, and Baldur's Gate 3 stays true to this tradition by ensuring that your decisions have meaningful and lasting effects on the world and its inhabitants.

In summary, letting the Emperor consume Orpheus in Baldur's Gate 3 is a complex decision with significant consequences. It can provide a tactical advantage in the final battle but comes at the cost of alienating Lae'zel and potentially destabilizing the Githyanki people. Careful consideration of your party's goals, your relationship with Lae'zel, and the moral implications of your choice is essential to making the best decision for your playthrough.