What happens if I let Astarion refuse ascension in Baldur's Gate 3?

In Baldur's Gate 3, Astarion is a complex companion with a deeply personal questline that revolves around his vampiric nature and his desire for power. One of the key moments in his story is the choice to ascend or refuse ascension during his personal quest, "The Pale Elf." This decision has significant consequences for Astarion's character, your relationship with him, and the overall story. Letting Astarion refuse ascension is a morally complex choice that requires careful consideration and specific actions during his questline.

To let Astarion refuse ascension, you must first progress through his personal quest, "The Pale Elf." This quest begins in Act 1 when you learn about Astarion's vampiric nature and his desire to break free from his master, Cazador Szarr. As you progress through the game, you will encounter more information about Cazador and Astarion's past, culminating in a confrontation with Cazador in Act 3. During this confrontation, Astarion will have the opportunity to perform a ritual that would grant him immense power, effectively allowing him to ascend to a more powerful form of vampire. However, this ritual requires the sacrifice of thousands of souls, including those of his fellow spawn.

The mechanics of this choice are tied to your dialogue options and the approval system. Astarion's approval of your character plays a significant role in whether he will listen to your advice or follow his own desires. If you have built a strong relationship with Astarion and have high approval, you can influence his decision during the ritual. To achieve this, you must consistently make choices that align with Astarion's personality and desires throughout the game. This includes supporting his autonomy, respecting his boundaries, and encouraging him to embrace his freedom rather than seeking power at any cost.

When you reach the confrontation with Cazador in Act 3, you will have the opportunity to persuade Astarion to refuse the ritual. This requires a successful Persuasion check, which can be challenging depending on your character's Charisma and proficiency in Persuasion. If you succeed, Astarion will choose not to ascend, sparing the lives of the spawn and rejecting the power offered by the ritual. This decision has a profound impact on Astarion's character development, as he chooses to embrace his humanity and reject the cycle of abuse and power that has defined his life.

There are several important tips and considerations to keep in mind when attempting to let Astarion refuse ascension. First, it is crucial to build a strong relationship with Astarion throughout the game. This means consistently making choices that increase his approval, such as supporting his autonomy, respecting his boundaries, and encouraging him to embrace his freedom. Additionally, it is important to have a high Charisma score and proficiency in Persuasion to increase your chances of successfully persuading him to refuse the ritual.

Common mistakes to avoid include neglecting Astarion's approval or making choices that alienate him. If Astarion's approval is too low, he may not listen to your advice and may choose to ascend regardless of your efforts. Additionally, failing the Persuasion check during the confrontation with Cazador will result in Astarion choosing to ascend, so it is important to ensure that your character is well-prepared for this moment.

Advanced techniques and optimizations include using spells or abilities that can increase your chances of success during the Persuasion check. For example, the Guidance spell, which can be cast by a cleric or druid, provides a bonus to ability checks, including Persuasion. Additionally, having a high Charisma score and proficiency in Persuasion will significantly increase your chances of success. It is also helpful to save your game before the confrontation with Cazador, allowing you to retry the Persuasion check if you fail.

In terms of related D&D rules and mechanics, the Persuasion check is a Charisma-based ability check that determines how well your character can influence others. The difficulty of the check is determined by the Dungeon Master (or, in this case, the game's mechanics), and the outcome can have significant consequences for the story. In Baldur's Gate 3, the Persuasion check to convince Astarion to refuse ascension is a high-stakes moment that requires careful preparation and strategy.

Specific examples and scenarios include the dialogue options during the confrontation with Cazador. When Astarion is faced with the choice to ascend, you will have the opportunity to persuade him to refuse the ritual. The dialogue options will vary depending on your character's relationship with Astarion and your previous choices throughout the game. If you have built a strong relationship with Astarion and have high approval, you will have more options to persuade him to refuse the ritual. Conversely, if your relationship with Astarion is strained, you may have fewer options and a lower chance of success.

In conclusion, letting Astarion refuse ascension in Baldur's Gate 3 is a morally complex choice that requires careful consideration and specific actions during his personal questline. By building a strong relationship with Astarion, increasing your Charisma and Persuasion skills, and making choices that align with his desires for freedom and autonomy, you can influence his decision and help him reject the cycle of abuse and power. This decision has significant consequences for Astarion's character development and your relationship with him, making it a pivotal moment in the game.