How do I increase approval with all companions simultaneously in Baldur's Gate 3?

Increasing approval with all companions simultaneously in Baldur's Gate 3 can be a challenging but rewarding task. The game's approval system is based on how your actions and dialogue choices align with each companion's personality, values, and goals. Since companions have different preferences, it can be tricky to find actions that please everyone. However, with careful planning and understanding of their individual traits, you can maximize approval across the board.

First, let's break down the mechanics. Each companion has an approval rating that ranges from -100 to +100. Positive actions and dialogue choices increase their approval, while negative ones decrease it. High approval can lead to deeper relationships, romance opportunities, and unique story outcomes. Low approval can result in companions leaving the party or even turning hostile. The key to increasing approval with all companions is to focus on actions and choices that are universally positive or at least neutral for most characters.

One effective strategy is to prioritize decisions that align with the greater good or moral integrity. Companions like Shadowheart, Gale, and Wyll generally approve of selfless, heroic actions. For example, helping NPCs in need, showing compassion, and standing up against injustice are choices that tend to gain approval from these characters. Astarion, on the other hand, often prefers more pragmatic or self-serving decisions. However, even he can appreciate cleverness and resourcefulness, so finding a balance is crucial.

A step-by-step approach to increasing approval involves the following. First, always consider the context of a situation. For instance, when encountering a group of goblins, you might have the option to negotiate, fight, or sneak past them. Negotiating or finding a peaceful solution can appeal to companions like Gale and Wyll, while Astarion might appreciate a more cunning approach. Second, pay attention to dialogue options. Some choices are clearly marked as "good" or "evil," but others are more nuanced. Try to pick options that reflect a balanced approach, such as being diplomatic or using humor to defuse tension.

Another important tip is to involve companions in conversations and decisions. When you have the option to let a companion speak or take the lead, doing so can increase their approval. For example, letting Shadowheart handle interactions with other followers of Shar or allowing Astarion to use his charm in social situations can boost their approval. Additionally, completing companion-specific quests and supporting their personal goals is a surefire way to gain their favor. For instance, helping Gale recover magical artifacts or aiding Shadowheart in her search for answers about her past will significantly increase their approval.

Common mistakes to avoid include making extreme choices that alienate certain companions. For example, siding with the goblins in Act 1 will likely anger Wyll and Karlach, while being overly altruistic might frustrate Astarion. It's also important to avoid neglecting companions in your party. Rotate your party members regularly to ensure everyone gets a chance to participate in key events and conversations. This not only helps with approval but also provides a more balanced gameplay experience.

Advanced techniques involve leveraging the game's mechanics to your advantage. For example, using the "Friends" cantrip or similar charm effects can make social interactions easier, but be cautious, as some companions may disapprove of manipulation. Additionally, understanding the D&D 5E rules that underpin the game can help you make informed decisions. For instance, knowing how alignment and moral choices work in D&D can guide you in selecting actions that align with your companions' values.

Specific examples of actions that generally increase approval include saving the tieflings in the Druid Grove, showing kindness to animals, and resolving conflicts peacefully. For instance, rescuing the child from the harpies or helping the tiefling blacksmith will earn you points with most companions. On the other hand, actions like stealing, betraying allies, or being unnecessarily cruel will decrease approval with many characters.

In conclusion, increasing approval with all companions simultaneously requires a balanced approach that considers each character's unique preferences. By focusing on universally positive actions, involving companions in decisions, and avoiding extreme choices, you can build strong relationships with your entire party. Remember to rotate your companions, complete their personal quests, and pay attention to dialogue options to maximize approval. With patience and careful planning, you can create a harmonious and loyal group of adventurers in Baldur's Gate 3.