How do I increase approval with Karlach in Baldur's Gate 3?

Increasing approval with Karlach in Baldur's Gate 3 involves understanding her personality, values, and the types of decisions she favors. Karlach is a tiefling barbarian with a strong sense of justice, loyalty, and a desire to protect the innocent. She appreciates bold, courageous actions and has a disdain for cowardice, cruelty, and manipulation. To build a strong relationship with her, you need to align your choices with her moral compass and engage in dialogue and actions that resonate with her ideals.

The approval system in Baldur's Gate 3 is based on how your decisions and dialogue choices align with a companion's personality and values. Each companion has a hidden approval rating that increases or decreases based on your actions. For Karlach, this means making choices that demonstrate bravery, standing up for the weak, and showing compassion. Conversely, actions that involve deceit, cruelty, or selfishness will lower her approval. The approval system is dynamic and can change throughout the game, so consistency in your choices is key.

To increase Karlach's approval, start by engaging in conversations with her at camp or during exploration. Pay attention to her dialogue and respond in ways that reflect her values. For example, if she expresses frustration with injustice or cruelty, agree with her and express a desire to fight against such evils. During key story moments, choose options that prioritize helping others or taking bold, decisive action. For instance, siding with tieflings in conflicts or defending innocent NPCs will earn her approval. Additionally, completing her personal quest, which involves resolving her past and helping her confront her demons, will significantly boost her approval.

Combat can also influence Karlach's approval. She admires bravery and strength, so taking risks in battle, such as charging into the fray or protecting allies, will earn her respect. Conversely, avoiding combat or using underhanded tactics like excessive stealth or manipulation may lower her approval. When building your party, consider including Karlach in situations where her skills as a barbarian can shine, such as in tough fights or when facing overwhelming odds. This not only strengthens your bond but also makes her feel valued as a companion.

One common mistake to avoid is making choices that prioritize personal gain over the greater good. Karlach values selflessness and heroism, so actions that involve exploiting others or prioritizing your own interests will harm your relationship with her. Additionally, avoid being overly cautious or indecisive, as she respects boldness and decisiveness. Another mistake is neglecting her personal quest. Failing to engage with her backstory or ignoring her requests for help will prevent you from deepening your relationship.

Advanced techniques for increasing Karlach's approval include leveraging her barbarian class mechanics. For example, using her Rage ability effectively in combat and allowing her to take the lead in dangerous situations will make her feel appreciated. Additionally, role-playing as a character with a similar moral alignment, such as a paladin or fighter with a strong sense of justice, can naturally align your choices with her values. This creates a synergy that makes it easier to gain her approval without having to constantly second-guess your decisions.

In terms of D&D 5E rules, Karlach's approval system reflects the alignment and personality traits of her character. As a barbarian, she embodies the chaotic good alignment, valuing freedom, courage, and protecting the innocent. Understanding these traits can help you predict how she will react to certain choices. For example, chaotic good characters often favor actions that promote freedom and justice, even if they involve breaking rules or taking risks.

Specific examples of actions that increase Karlach's approval include defending the tiefling refugees in the Emerald Grove, standing up to bullies or tyrants, and showing compassion to those in need. For instance, during the confrontation with Kagha in the Emerald Grove, siding with the tieflings and opposing her oppressive actions will earn Karlach's approval. Similarly, in Act 2, helping the Harpers and defending Last Light Inn from threats will resonate with her values.

In summary, increasing Karlach's approval requires aligning your choices with her values of bravery, justice, and compassion. Engage in dialogue that reflects her ideals, make bold and selfless decisions, and prioritize her personal quest. Avoid actions that involve cruelty, manipulation, or cowardice, and leverage her barbarian strengths in combat. By consistently demonstrating these qualities, you can build a strong and meaningful relationship with Karlach in Baldur's Gate 3.