What are the best dialogue choices to increase Karlach's approval in Baldur's Gate 3?

Increasing Karlach's approval in Baldur's Gate 3 involves understanding her personality, values, and the types of decisions she respects. Karlach is a tiefling barbarian with a strong sense of justice, loyalty, and a desire to protect the innocent. She appreciates boldness, honesty, and acts of heroism, but she dislikes deceit, cruelty, and selfishness. To maximize her approval, you need to align your dialogue choices and actions with these traits.

First, let's discuss the mechanics of approval. Approval is a hidden value that increases or decreases based on your choices and actions. Each companion has their own approval rating, which affects their loyalty, dialogue options, and potential for romance. Karlach's approval can be checked indirectly through her reactions to your decisions, but there is no numerical display in the game. High approval can lead to deeper conversations, personal quests, and romantic opportunities, while low approval may result in her leaving the party or becoming hostile.

To increase Karlach's approval, focus on making choices that reflect bravery, kindness, and a willingness to help others. For example, when encountering situations where you can defend the weak or stand up to bullies, choose the dialogue options that align with these values. In the early game, during the encounter with the tieflings and goblins at the Druid Grove, siding with the tieflings and helping them defend their home will earn Karlach's approval. She respects those who fight for justice and protect the innocent.

Another key moment is during the interactions with the goblins. If you choose to infiltrate the goblin camp, Karlach will appreciate it if you take a direct and bold approach rather than resorting to deceit. For instance, when speaking with the goblin leaders, choosing dialogue options that show confidence and a willingness to confront them head-on will earn her approval. However, if you choose to manipulate or deceive the goblins, Karlach may disapprove, as she values honesty and straightforwardness.

In combat, Karlach's approval can also be influenced by your tactics. She respects bold and aggressive strategies, so using her barbarian abilities to charge into battle and deal heavy damage will align with her personality. Additionally, protecting your allies and prioritizing the safety of innocent NPCs during combat will earn her approval. For example, if you encounter a situation where civilians are in danger, make sure to prioritize their safety over other objectives.

When it comes to personal interactions with Karlach, be honest and direct. She appreciates characters who are upfront about their intentions and who show genuine concern for others. During her personal quest, which involves her past and her connection to the infernal engine, make choices that show empathy and a willingness to help her resolve her issues. Avoid making decisions that seem selfish or dismissive of her struggles.

One common mistake to avoid is making choices that prioritize personal gain over the well-being of others. Karlach disapproves of greed and selfishness, so actions like stealing from innocent NPCs or betraying allies for personal benefit will lower her approval. Additionally, avoid using deception or manipulation in situations where a more direct approach is possible. Karlach values honesty and integrity, so these types of actions will not sit well with her.

Advanced techniques for increasing Karlach's approval include leveraging her barbarian abilities in combat to maximize her effectiveness and aligning your party composition to complement her strengths. For example, pairing her with a cleric or paladin who can provide healing and support will allow her to focus on dealing damage without worrying about her health. Additionally, choosing dialogue options that reflect a strong moral compass and a willingness to take risks for the greater good will consistently earn her approval.

In terms of related D&D rules and mechanics, Karlach's approval system is based on the alignment system in Dungeons & Dragons. She aligns with the chaotic good archetype, valuing freedom, individuality, and the protection of others. Understanding this alignment can help you predict her reactions to various choices and tailor your actions accordingly.

Specific examples of scenarios where you can increase Karlach's approval include the encounter with the owlbear in the cave. Choosing to spare the owlbear and its cub, rather than killing them, will earn her approval. Similarly, during the confrontation with the paladins of Tyr, siding with Karlach and defending her against their accusations will significantly increase her approval. These moments highlight her values of compassion and loyalty, and aligning with them will strengthen your relationship.

In summary, increasing Karlach's approval in Baldur's Gate 3 requires making choices that reflect bravery, honesty, and a commitment to protecting the innocent. By understanding her personality and values, and aligning your actions with them, you can build a strong relationship with her and unlock deeper interactions and potential romance. Avoid selfish or deceitful actions, and prioritize bold, heroic decisions to earn her respect and approval.