How do I get Shadowheart to trust me in Baldur's Gate 3?

To gain Shadowheart's trust in Baldur's Gate 3, you need to focus on building her approval through your actions, dialogue choices, and decisions throughout the game. Shadowheart is a complex character with a mysterious past tied to her devotion to Shar, the goddess of darkness and loss. Her trust is not easily earned, as she is guarded and often skeptical of others. However, by understanding her personality and values, you can make choices that align with her worldview and gradually win her over.

The primary mechanic for building trust with Shadowheart is the approval system. Each companion has an approval rating that increases or decreases based on your actions and dialogue choices. Shadowheart tends to approve of pragmatic, cautious, and secretive behavior, as well as decisions that prioritize survival and self-interest. She also values loyalty and respect for her privacy. To gain her trust, you should avoid actions that are overly altruistic, reckless, or invasive, as these will lower her approval.

One of the first steps to building trust with Shadowheart is to respect her boundaries. Early in the game, she will ask you not to pry into her past or her connection to Shar. If you press her for information or try to force her to open up, she will become defensive and her approval will drop. Instead, show patience and let her reveal her secrets at her own pace. For example, when she mentions her devotion to Shar, you can respond with understanding or curiosity without being pushy. This demonstrates that you respect her autonomy and are willing to trust her on her terms.

Another key strategy is to align your decisions with Shadowheart's values. She appreciates when you prioritize the safety and well-being of your party over unnecessary risks. For instance, during the encounter with the goblins at the Druid Grove, siding with the tieflings and defending the grove will earn her approval, as it shows a commitment to protecting your allies. Similarly, when dealing with the goblin leaders, choosing diplomatic or stealthy approaches over outright violence can also please her, as it reflects a preference for cunning and strategy.

Shadowheart also approves of decisions that involve deception or manipulation when it serves a greater purpose. For example, if you encounter the githyanki patrol and choose to deceive them rather than engage in combat, Shadowheart will appreciate your cleverness. However, be cautious not to overuse deception or betrayals, as she values loyalty and may disapprove if your actions harm the party or undermine her trust.

Combat tactics can also play a role in building Shadowheart's trust. As a cleric, she excels in healing and support, so ensuring her survival and effectiveness in battle will strengthen your bond. Positioning her strategically to heal and buff your party members, while also dealing damage with her spells, will demonstrate your competence as a leader. Additionally, protecting her from harm and reviving her if she falls in combat will show that you value her as a companion.

One common mistake to avoid is making decisions that are overly idealistic or self-sacrificing. Shadowheart is pragmatic and values practicality over idealism. For example, if you choose to spare an enemy who poses a threat to the party, she may disapprove, as she sees it as a needless risk. Similarly, being overly trusting of strangers or revealing too much about your own plans can make her wary of your judgment.

Advanced techniques for gaining Shadowheart's trust include completing her personal quest, which involves uncovering the truth about her past and her connection to Shar. As you progress through the game, you will encounter opportunities to learn more about her background and help her resolve her inner conflicts. Supporting her in these moments and respecting her choices will significantly increase her approval and deepen your relationship.

In terms of D&D rules and mechanics, Shadowheart's approval system is influenced by her alignment and personality traits. As a cleric of Shar, she leans toward a neutral or neutral evil alignment, valuing self-preservation and the pursuit of power. Understanding these traits can help you make choices that align with her worldview and earn her trust.

Specific examples of actions that increase Shadowheart's approval include siding with her in disagreements with other companions, such as when she clashes with Lae'zel over their differing views on the githyanki. Additionally, showing compassion and understanding when she reveals her vulnerabilities, such as her fear of wolves, will earn her respect and trust.

In summary, gaining Shadowheart's trust requires a combination of respecting her boundaries, aligning your decisions with her values, and demonstrating competence and loyalty in combat and social interactions. By focusing on these strategies and avoiding common mistakes, you can build a strong relationship with Shadowheart and unlock the full potential of her character in Baldur's Gate 3.