How do I resolve all companion conflicts in Baldur's Gate 3?

Resolving companion conflicts in Baldur's Gate 3 involves understanding the approval system, making thoughtful dialogue choices, and completing personal quests. Each companion has unique preferences, backstories, and triggers that influence their approval or disapproval of your actions. To resolve conflicts and maintain positive relationships, you need to balance their individual needs with your overall goals.

First, let's discuss the approval mechanics. Each companion has an approval rating that ranges from -100 to +100. This rating is influenced by your dialogue choices, actions, and decisions throughout the game. High approval leads to stronger bonds, potential romance, and better cooperation in combat. Low approval can result in conflicts, companions leaving the party, or even hostile encounters. To manage approval, pay attention to each companion's personality and values. For example, Astarion appreciates cunning and self-serving actions, while Shadowheart values discretion and loyalty to her deity, Shar.

Step-by-step, here's how to resolve conflicts and maintain high approval. Start by recruiting all companions early in the game. You can find Shadowheart on the Nautiloid ship, Astarion near the crash site, Gale at the Roadside Cliffs, and Lae'zel in a cage near the Tiefling camp. Once recruited, engage in regular conversations with them at camp to learn about their personalities and preferences. During dialogues, choose options that align with their values. For example, when dealing with Astarion, opt for sarcastic or pragmatic responses. With Gale, show curiosity and respect for magic.

Completing personal quests is crucial for resolving conflicts. Each companion has a unique questline that delves into their backstory and motivations. For instance, Shadowheart's quest involves her connection to Shar and her mysterious artifact. Astarion's quest revolves around his vampiric origins and his former master, Cazador. Progressing these quests not only boosts approval but also unlocks deeper character development and potential romance options. Make sure to prioritize these quests and make choices that align with the companion's goals.

Important tips include avoiding actions that universally displease companions. For example, unnecessary cruelty or recklessness can lower approval across the board. Additionally, be mindful of party composition. Some companions may disapprove of each other's presence, so rotate party members based on the situation. For instance, Lae'zel and Shadowheart often clash due to their conflicting beliefs, so avoid bringing them together in tense situations.

Common mistakes to avoid include neglecting companion interactions or making decisions without considering their perspectives. Skipping camp conversations or ignoring personal quests can lead to missed opportunities for approval gains. Another mistake is forcing companions into situations that conflict with their values. For example, forcing Astarion to act selflessly or pressuring Shadowheart to abandon her faith can lead to disapproval.

Advanced techniques involve leveraging the game's mechanics to optimize approval. For example, use the "Speak with Dead" spell to gather information that aligns with a companion's interests. Additionally, use the "Friends" cantrip to gain advantage on persuasion checks, but be cautious, as some companions may disapprove of magical manipulation. Another strategy is to use the "Guidance" cantrip to boost skill checks during critical moments in companion quests.

Related D&D rules and mechanics include the influence of alignment and role-playing. In D&D, alignment reflects a character's moral and ethical stance. While Baldur's Gate 3 doesn't explicitly use alignment, companions have implicit alignments that guide their reactions. For example, Astarion leans towards chaotic neutral, while Wyll is more lawful good. Understanding these implicit alignments can help you predict their reactions to your choices.

Specific examples include resolving the conflict between Lae'zel and Shadowheart. Early in the game, these two companions may argue over the artifact Shadowheart carries. To mediate, choose dialogue options that de-escalate the situation and show neutrality. Another example is dealing with Astarion's vampirism. When he reveals his condition, support his need for blood to gain his trust, but set boundaries to avoid alienating other companions.

In summary, resolving companion conflicts in Baldur's Gate 3 requires a combination of understanding approval mechanics, making thoughtful choices, and completing personal quests. By paying attention to each companion's preferences and balancing their needs with your goals, you can build strong relationships and resolve conflicts effectively. Avoid common mistakes, use advanced techniques, and leverage D&D mechanics to optimize your interactions. With careful planning and role-playing, you can create a cohesive and loyal party that enhances your journey through the game.