What happens if I let Shadowheart become a Dark Justiciar in Baldur's Gate 3?

Allowing Shadowheart to become a Dark Justiciar in Baldur's Gate 3 is a significant story choice that impacts her character arc, your relationship with her, and the overall narrative. This transformation occurs during her personal quest, "The Chosen of Shar," which is tied to her devotion to the goddess Shar, the Mistress of the Night. To achieve this outcome, you must guide Shadowheart through a series of decisions that align with Shar's teachings and ultimately lead her to embrace her role as a Dark Justiciar. HereÔÇÖs a detailed breakdown of how to achieve this, along with important considerations and strategies.

First, itÔÇÖs important to understand the mechanics of ShadowheartÔÇÖs approval system. ShadowheartÔÇÖs approval of your actions and decisions is crucial to unlocking her personal quest and influencing her choices. She favors pragmatic, secretive, and sometimes ruthless decisions, especially those that align with SharÔÇÖs ideology. To build her approval, make choices that prioritize survival, secrecy, and the greater good, even if they come at a moral cost. For example, siding with her in disagreements, avoiding unnecessary risks, and showing respect for her faith will increase her approval. Conversely, overly altruistic or reckless decisions may lower her approval and make it harder to guide her toward becoming a Dark Justiciar.

The key moment in ShadowheartÔÇÖs questline occurs in Act 2, specifically in the Gauntlet of Shar. This dungeon is filled with trials that test her devotion to Shar. To progress, you must complete these trials, which involve solving puzzles, defeating enemies, and making choices that reflect SharÔÇÖs values. One of the most critical decisions comes at the end of the Gauntlet, where Shadowheart is faced with the choice to spare or kill a specific NPC tied to her past. To ensure she becomes a Dark Justiciar, you must encourage her to kill this NPC, as this act solidifies her commitment to Shar and her path as a Dark Justiciar.

During this pivotal moment, dialogue choices matter greatly. You should support her decision to embrace SharÔÇÖs teachings and avoid dissuading her from her path. If her approval of you is high enough, she will trust your guidance and follow through with the act. If her approval is low or if youÔÇÖve made choices that conflict with SharÔÇÖs ideology, she may hesitate or even reject the path of a Dark Justiciar. Therefore, maintaining her approval throughout the game is essential.

There are several tips and considerations to keep in mind. First, ensure Shadowheart is in your active party during Act 2, as her personal quest is tied to this act. Missing key moments in the Gauntlet of Shar can lock you out of this outcome. Second, pay attention to her dialogue and reactions to your choices. If she expresses doubt or conflict about her faith, it may indicate that her approval is not high enough or that youÔÇÖve made choices that conflict with SharÔÇÖs teachings. Third, be prepared for combat in the Gauntlet of Shar, as some trials involve challenging enemies. Optimize ShadowheartÔÇÖs build for support and healing, as her role as a Cleric will be crucial in these encounters.

Common mistakes to avoid include neglecting her approval, making choices that conflict with SharÔÇÖs ideology, or failing to bring her along for key story moments. Additionally, rushing through the Gauntlet of Shar without completing all trials can prevent her from fully embracing her role as a Dark Justiciar. Take your time to explore the dungeon and ensure all trials are completed.

Advanced techniques involve optimizing ShadowheartÔÇÖs build to maximize her effectiveness in combat and support roles. As a Cleric, she excels in healing, buffing, and controlling the battlefield. Consider multiclassing her with a class like Paladin or Rogue to enhance her combat capabilities, but be mindful of how this affects her role as a Dark Justiciar. Additionally, use her unique abilities, such as her Channel Divinity and Shar-related spells, to their fullest potential.

From a D&D 5E rules perspective, ShadowheartÔÇÖs transformation into a Dark Justiciar aligns with the concept of a character embracing an archetype or subclass tied to their deity. In her case, this reflects her devotion to Shar and her willingness to follow the path of darkness. This transformation also has narrative consequences, as it affects her relationships with other companions and the overall story.

In summary, allowing Shadowheart to become a Dark Justiciar requires careful attention to her approval, alignment with SharÔÇÖs teachings, and completion of her personal quest in Act 2. By following these steps and avoiding common mistakes, you can guide her down this dark and transformative path, unlocking a unique and compelling story outcome.