What are the best dialogue choices to increase Karlach's approval in Baldur's Gate 3?

Increasing Karlach's approval in Baldur's Gate 3 involves understanding her personality, values, and the types of decisions she respects. Karlach is a tiefling barbarian with a strong sense of justice, loyalty, and a desire to protect the innocent. She appreciates boldness, honesty, and acts of heroism, but she dislikes deceit, cruelty, and selfishness. To build a strong relationship with her, you need to align your choices with these traits.

The approval system in Baldur's Gate 3 is based on dialogue choices, actions, and decisions you make throughout the game. Each companion has a hidden approval rating that increases or decreases based on how they perceive your behavior. For Karlach, you want to focus on making choices that demonstrate courage, kindness, and a willingness to stand up for others. Here are some strategies to increase her approval:

1. Be Honest and Direct: Karlach values straightforwardness. In conversations, choose dialogue options that are honest and direct rather than manipulative or deceitful. For example, if you encounter a situation where you can lie to gain an advantage, avoid it. Instead, opt for the truth, even if it makes things more difficult.

2. Protect the Innocent: Karlach has a strong moral compass and admires those who protect the weak. Whenever you encounter situations where innocent people are in danger, prioritize helping them. For instance, if you come across refugees or villagers in trouble, intervene on their behalf. Karlach will approve of your actions if you show compassion and bravery.

3. Stand Up to Bullies: Karlach despises those who abuse their power. If you encounter characters who are bullying or oppressing others, confront them. For example, if you meet a group of bandits harassing travelers, choose to fight them rather than negotiate or ignore the situation. Karlach will respect your willingness to stand up for what is right.

4. Avoid Selfishness: Karlach dislikes selfish behavior. Avoid making decisions that prioritize your own gain over the well-being of others. For example, if you find a valuable item that belongs to someone else, return it rather than keeping it for yourself. Similarly, if you are offered a reward for helping someone, consider refusing it or sharing it with others.

5. Show Loyalty to Your Companions: Karlach values loyalty and camaraderie. When interacting with other companions, support them and show solidarity. For example, if a companion is being criticized or challenged, defend them. Karlach will appreciate your loyalty to the group.

6. Engage in Her Personal Quest: As you progress through the game, Karlach will share her personal story and quest. Pay attention to her dialogue and take her concerns seriously. Completing her personal quest and making choices that align with her values will significantly increase her approval.

Common mistakes to avoid include making decisions that are cruel, deceitful, or self-serving. For example, betraying allies, stealing from innocents, or siding with oppressive forces will lower Karlach's approval. Additionally, avoid being overly cautious or indecisive, as Karlach respects boldness and action.

Advanced techniques involve leveraging your character's class and abilities to align with Karlach's values. For example, if you are playing a paladin or cleric, your class's emphasis on justice and protection will naturally align with Karlach's preferences. Similarly, if you are playing a rogue or bard, focus on using your skills to help others rather than for personal gain.

In terms of D&D rules, Karlach's approval system reflects the alignment system in Dungeons & Dragons. Karlach is aligned with chaotic good, meaning she values freedom, individuality, and doing what is right, even if it means breaking the rules. Understanding this alignment can help you make decisions that resonate with her.

Specific examples of scenarios where you can increase Karlach's approval include the encounter with the goblins at the Druid Grove. If you choose to defend the grove and protect the tieflings, Karlach will approve. Another example is the interaction with the paladins of Tyr. If you side with Karlach and confront the paladins, she will respect your decision.

In summary, increasing Karlach's approval in Baldur's Gate 3 requires making choices that reflect bravery, honesty, and a commitment to protecting others. By understanding her values and aligning your actions with them, you can build a strong relationship with her and unlock deeper interactions and storylines.