How do I increase approval with Astarion without being evil in Baldur's Gate 3?

Increasing approval with Astarion in Baldur's Gate 3 without resorting to evil actions is entirely possible, though it requires a nuanced approach. Astarion, as a character, tends to favor choices that reflect self-interest, cunning, and a certain level of ruthlessness. However, this doesn't mean you have to be outright evil to gain his approval. Understanding his personality and the mechanics of approval will help you navigate this relationship effectively.

First, let's discuss the mechanics of approval. Approval in Baldur's Gate 3 is influenced by the choices you make during dialogues, quests, and interactions with other characters. Each companion has their own set of preferences, and Astarion's approval is tied to actions that align with his self-serving and pragmatic nature. The game uses a hidden approval rating system, where certain choices will increase or decrease his approval. You can gauge his approval through his reactions in dialogue and his overall demeanor towards you.

To increase Astarion's approval without being evil, focus on choices that demonstrate cleverness, independence, and a willingness to bend the rules. For example, during the early stages of the game, when you encounter the dying Mind Flayer on the Nautiloid ship, you can choose to ignore it and move on. Astarion will appreciate this pragmatic approach. Similarly, when you meet the Tieflings who have captured Lae'zel, siding with them but then finding a way to free Lae'zel without direct confrontation can earn you points with Astarion.

Another key strategy is to support Astarion's personal quests and backstory. As you progress through the game, you'll learn more about his past and his struggles. Showing empathy and understanding towards his situation, while also encouraging him to embrace his newfound freedom, will earn his approval. For instance, when he reveals his vampiric nature, reacting with curiosity rather than fear or disgust will help build trust.

In terms of combat tactics, Astarion is a Rogue, so he excels in stealth, sneak attacks, and dealing high damage from the shadows. Positioning him effectively in combat and using his abilities to their fullest potential will not only make him more effective in battle but also show that you value his skills. This can indirectly boost his approval, as he appreciates being recognized for his talents.

One common mistake to avoid is being overly altruistic or self-sacrificing. While Astarion doesn't necessarily disapprove of all good deeds, he tends to favor actions that benefit him directly or show a willingness to prioritize survival over morality. For example, when dealing with the Druid Grove and the Goblin Camp, choosing to side with the Goblins might seem like an evil choice, but you can find a middle ground by negotiating or finding alternative solutions that don't involve outright betrayal.

Advanced techniques involve leveraging the game's dialogue system to your advantage. Pay close attention to Astarion's reactions during conversations and choose options that align with his worldview. For instance, when discussing the tadpole in your head, expressing a desire to use its powers rather than seeking a cure can earn his approval. Additionally, engaging in banter and humor with him, especially when it involves mocking others or showing a lack of concern for societal norms, can also help.

Related D&D rules and mechanics come into play when considering Astarion's class and abilities. As a Rogue, he relies on Dexterity and Charisma, so building a character that complements these traits can enhance your synergy with him. For example, a Bard or Sorcerer with high Charisma can engage in persuasive dialogues that align with Astarion's preferences, while a Fighter or Ranger can provide the necessary combat support to make him shine in battle.

Specific examples include the interaction with the Hag in the Sunlit Wetlands. If you choose to deceive the Hag or find a way to outsmart her without resorting to violence, Astarion will appreciate the cunning involved. Similarly, during the quest involving the Necromancy of Thay, allowing Astarion to take the lead and showing interest in the dark knowledge within the book will earn his approval.

In summary, increasing Astarion's approval without being evil involves a combination of clever dialogue choices, supporting his personal quests, and leveraging his strengths in combat. By understanding his character and the mechanics of approval, you can build a strong relationship with him while staying true to your own moral compass.