What are the best gifts or items to give companions in Baldur's Gate 3?

In Baldur's Gate 3, building strong relationships with your companions is a key part of the game. Giving gifts or items to your companions can help improve their approval of you, which is crucial for deepening your relationships, unlocking romance options, and progressing their personal quests. HereÔÇÖs a detailed guide on how to approach this aspect of the game.

First, itÔÇÖs important to understand the approval mechanics. Each companion has an approval rating that changes based on your actions, dialogue choices, and decisions throughout the game. Giving gifts or items that align with a companionÔÇÖs personality or needs can boost their approval. However, the game does not have a direct ÔÇ£gift-givingÔÇØ mechanic like some other RPGs. Instead, you can influence approval by offering items during specific interactions or by making choices that reflect their values.

For example, Shadowheart, a cleric of Shar, values secrecy and pragmatism. Giving her items related to her faith, such as Sharran artifacts or items that enhance her stealth and spellcasting abilities, can improve her approval. Similarly, Astarion, a rogue with a dark past, appreciates items that enhance his cunning and dexterity, such as lockpicks or daggers. Gale, a wizard, values knowledge and magical items, so giving him scrolls or magical artifacts can make him more favorable toward you.

To give items to companions, you can open the trade menu during dialogue or while managing your inventory. Simply select the item you want to give and transfer it to their inventory. Keep in mind that not all items will have an immediate effect on approval. Some items may only be useful in specific quests or interactions, so itÔÇÖs important to pay attention to the context.

One effective strategy is to pay attention to your companionsÔÇÖ personal quests and backstories. For example, during ShadowheartÔÇÖs personal quest, you may find items that are directly tied to her past or her faith. Offering these items to her at the right moment can significantly boost her approval. Similarly, AstarionÔÇÖs quest involves his vampiric nature, so items related to blood or his transformation can be meaningful to him.

Another important tip is to consider the timing of your gifts. Giving an item during a pivotal moment in a companionÔÇÖs quest or after a significant event can have a greater impact than giving it randomly. For example, giving Gale a powerful magical item after he expresses a need for it during his personal quest can lead to a substantial approval boost.

Common mistakes to avoid include giving items that donÔÇÖt align with a companionÔÇÖs personality or needs. For example, giving Astarion a holy symbol or a book on morality might not sit well with him, as it contradicts his rogueish and self-serving nature. Similarly, giving Shadowheart a book on Sel├╗ne, the enemy of her goddess Shar, could lower her approval.

Advanced techniques involve using gifts to manipulate approval in specific ways. For example, if youÔÇÖre trying to romance a companion, giving them items that align with their romantic preferences can help. Shadowheart, for instance, might appreciate a gift that shows you understand her secretive nature, while Astarion might respond well to a gift that reflects your shared sense of mischief.

In terms of D&D 5E rules, the approval system in BaldurÔÇÖs Gate 3 is a simplified version of the relationship mechanics found in tabletop D&D. In tabletop, relationships are often roleplayed and developed through interactions, but in BaldurÔÇÖs Gate 3, the game quantifies these relationships through the approval system. This makes it easier to track your progress with each companion but also requires you to be mindful of their individual preferences and values.

Specific examples include giving Shadowheart the Idol of Shar during her personal quest, which can significantly boost her approval and progress her story. For Astarion, giving him the Necromancy of Thay book can be a meaningful gesture, as it aligns with his dark interests. Gale, on the other hand, might appreciate a rare magical artifact like the Staff of Crones, which can aid him in his magical pursuits.

In conclusion, giving gifts or items to companions in BaldurÔÇÖs Gate 3 is a nuanced process that requires understanding their personalities, needs, and backstories. By paying attention to their approval mechanics, personal quests, and the context of your interactions, you can effectively build stronger relationships with your companions and unlock deeper storylines and romance options.