What happens if I let Shadowheart become a Dark Justiciar in Baldur's Gate 3?

Allowing Shadowheart to become a Dark Justiciar in Baldur's Gate 3 is a significant story decision that impacts her character arc, your relationship with her, and the overall narrative. This choice is tied to her personal quest, "The Chosen of Shar," which revolves around her devotion to the goddess Shar and her desire to prove herself as a true servant of darkness. To achieve this outcome, you must guide Shadowheart through a series of decisions and challenges that align with Shar's teachings. HereÔÇÖs a detailed breakdown of how to achieve this, along with important considerations and strategies.

First, to begin ShadowheartÔÇÖs journey toward becoming a Dark Justiciar, you must progress her personal questline. This starts early in the game when you recruit her, but it becomes more prominent in Act 2 when you reach the Shadow-Cursed Lands. In this region, you will encounter the Gauntlet of Shar, a dungeon dedicated to the goddess. This is where ShadowheartÔÇÖs fate as a Dark Justiciar is decided. The Gauntlet of Shar is filled with trials that test her devotion to Shar, and your choices during these trials will determine whether she embraces her destiny as a Dark Justiciar or rejects it.

The mechanics of this quest involve navigating the Gauntlet of Shar and completing its trials. These trials are designed to test ShadowheartÔÇÖs faith and resolve. For example, one trial requires you to solve a puzzle involving mirrors and light, while another involves combat against spectral enemies. Throughout these trials, you must encourage Shadowheart to stay true to SharÔÇÖs teachings. This means making dialogue choices that reflect her devotion to the goddess and avoiding actions that might lead her to question her faith. For instance, when faced with moral dilemmas, you should prioritize SharÔÇÖs values of secrecy, loss, and darkness over more altruistic or light-aligned choices.

One of the most critical moments in this questline occurs when you reach the Inner Sanctum of the Gauntlet of Shar. Here, Shadowheart will face a pivotal decision involving the Nightsong, a key figure tied to SharÔÇÖs plans. To ensure she becomes a Dark Justiciar, you must support her decision to kill the Nightsong. This act solidifies her commitment to Shar and unlocks her transformation into a Dark Justiciar. ItÔÇÖs important to note that this choice has significant consequences, as it aligns Shadowheart with SharÔÇÖs darker ideals and may strain her relationships with other party members who disapprove of such actions.

When guiding Shadowheart through this process, there are several tips and considerations to keep in mind. First, ensure that Shadowheart is in your active party during the Gauntlet of Shar. Her presence is essential for triggering the necessary dialogue and events. Second, pay close attention to her approval rating. ShadowheartÔÇÖs approval of your character influences her willingness to follow your guidance. To maintain her approval, make choices that align with her values, such as favoring secrecy, pragmatism, and loyalty to Shar. Avoid actions that prioritize kindness or selflessness, as these may conflict with her devotion to the goddess.

A common mistake to avoid is failing to prepare for the challenges in the Gauntlet of Shar. The trials can be difficult, especially if your party is not well-equipped or lacks the necessary skills. For example, the combat trial requires strong offensive capabilities, while the puzzle trial demands problem-solving skills. To optimize your chances of success, ensure your party is balanced and well-prepared. Consider bringing characters with high damage output, healing abilities, and utility spells. Additionally, stock up on healing potions and scrolls to handle unexpected challenges.

Advanced techniques for this questline involve leveraging ShadowheartÔÇÖs class abilities to their fullest potential. As a Cleric of Shar, she has access to powerful spells and abilities that can aid in combat and exploration. For example, her Channel Divinity: Turn Undead can be invaluable against the spectral enemies in the Gauntlet. Additionally, her healing spells can keep the party alive during tough encounters. Optimizing her spell selection and equipment can make a significant difference in overcoming the trials. Equip her with gear that enhances her spellcasting and survivability, such as items that boost her Wisdom or provide resistance to necrotic damage.

From a D&D rules perspective, ShadowheartÔÇÖs transformation into a Dark Justiciar reflects her alignment shift toward a darker path. In Dungeons & Dragons 5th Edition, alignment represents a characterÔÇÖs moral and ethical outlook. By embracing SharÔÇÖs teachings and becoming a Dark Justiciar, Shadowheart moves closer to a neutral evil alignment, prioritizing her devotion to Shar over other considerations. This alignment shift can influence her interactions with other characters and the overall story.

In conclusion, allowing Shadowheart to become a Dark Justiciar is a complex and impactful decision that requires careful planning and alignment with her values. By guiding her through the Gauntlet of Shar, supporting her devotion to Shar, and making choices that reflect her darker ideals, you can unlock this unique story outcome. Be mindful of her approval, prepare for the challenges ahead, and optimize her abilities to ensure success. This path not only deepens her character arc but also adds a layer of moral complexity to your journey in BaldurÔÇÖs Gate 3.