What are the consequences of letting Astarion kill the Gur hunter in Baldur's Gate 3?
In Baldur's Gate 3, the decision to let Astarion kill the Gur hunter, Gandrel, has significant consequences for both Astarion's personal questline and your relationship with him. This choice occurs during Act 1 when you encounter Gandrel, a Gur hunter who is searching for Astarion to bring him back to his people. The Gur are a nomadic group, and Gandrel has been tasked with capturing Astarion, who is a vampire spawn. The encounter takes place in the Sunlit Wetlands, and the outcome of this interaction can shape Astarion's character development and your party dynamics.
To let Astarion kill Gandrel, you must first encounter Gandrel in the Sunlit Wetlands. He will approach your party and ask if you have seen Astarion. At this point, you have several dialogue options. If you reveal Astarion's presence or if Astarion is in your party, he will confront Gandrel directly. Astarion will express his desire to kill Gandrel, and you will be given the choice to either support him or try to stop him. If you choose to let Astarion kill Gandrel, the Gur hunter will be slain, and Astarion will gain approval from you for allowing him to take revenge.
The mechanics involved in this decision revolve around the approval system in Baldur's Gate 3. Each companion has an approval rating that reflects their opinion of you based on your actions and dialogue choices. Letting Astarion kill Gandrel will increase his approval, as it aligns with his desire for vengeance and his distrust of those who seek to control him. This approval gain can be crucial if you are trying to build a strong relationship with Astarion, whether for friendship or romance. However, it is important to note that other companions, particularly those with a more moral or lawful alignment, may disapprove of this action.
Step-by-step, here is how you can let Astarion kill Gandrel. First, ensure that Astarion is in your party when you approach Gandrel. This is important because if Astarion is not present, you will not have the option to let him confront the hunter. When Gandrel asks about Astarion, choose dialogue options that reveal Astarion's presence or allow Astarion to step forward. Once Astarion confronts Gandrel, he will express his desire to kill the hunter. At this point, you can choose to support Astarion by letting him kill Gandrel. The combat will be relatively straightforward, as Gandrel is alone and not particularly powerful. After the fight, Astarion will express his satisfaction, and his approval of you will increase.
There are several important tips and considerations to keep in mind when making this decision. First, consider the moral implications of allowing Astarion to kill Gandrel. While it may strengthen your bond with Astarion, it could also alienate other companions who value justice and mercy. Additionally, killing Gandrel may have long-term consequences for the story, as the Gur are a significant group in the game's lore, and their questline may be affected by this action. If you are playing a character with a good or lawful alignment, you may want to think carefully before allowing this act of violence.
Common mistakes to avoid include not having Astarion in your party when you encounter Gandrel. If Astarion is not present, you will not have the option to let him kill the hunter, and the encounter will play out differently. Another mistake is failing to consider the approval ratings of other companions. While Astarion may approve of your decision, other party members may disapprove, which could affect their loyalty and willingness to support you in future quests.
Advanced techniques or optimizations involve using this decision to further your relationship with Astarion. If you are pursuing a romance with him, allowing him to kill Gandrel can be a significant step in gaining his trust and affection. Additionally, if you are playing a character with a more chaotic or evil alignment, this decision can align with your character's motivations and provide a satisfying role-playing experience.
In terms of related D&D rules and mechanics, this encounter reflects the alignment system and the concept of player choice. Astarion, as a vampire spawn, is inherently tied to themes of survival, revenge, and moral ambiguity. Allowing him to kill Gandrel is a decision that aligns with his chaotic and self-serving nature, while stopping him would reflect a more lawful or good-aligned approach. The approval system in Baldur's Gate 3 is a direct implementation of the D&D mechanics that govern relationships and character development.
Specific examples and scenarios include the potential impact on future interactions with the Gur. If you let Astarion kill Gandrel, you may encounter other Gur later in the game who are hostile towards you due to your actions. This can lead to additional combat encounters and story developments that are shaped by your earlier decision. Conversely, if you spare Gandrel, he may reappear later in the game with information or assistance that could benefit your party.
In conclusion, letting Astarion kill the Gur hunter Gandrel in Baldur's Gate 3 is a decision that has significant consequences for your relationship with Astarion and the overall story. It involves careful consideration of the approval system, the moral implications of your actions, and the potential long-term effects on the game's narrative. By following the steps outlined above and keeping these tips and considerations in mind, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your character's motivations and goals.
To let Astarion kill Gandrel, you must first encounter Gandrel in the Sunlit Wetlands. He will approach your party and ask if you have seen Astarion. At this point, you have several dialogue options. If you reveal Astarion's presence or if Astarion is in your party, he will confront Gandrel directly. Astarion will express his desire to kill Gandrel, and you will be given the choice to either support him or try to stop him. If you choose to let Astarion kill Gandrel, the Gur hunter will be slain, and Astarion will gain approval from you for allowing him to take revenge.
The mechanics involved in this decision revolve around the approval system in Baldur's Gate 3. Each companion has an approval rating that reflects their opinion of you based on your actions and dialogue choices. Letting Astarion kill Gandrel will increase his approval, as it aligns with his desire for vengeance and his distrust of those who seek to control him. This approval gain can be crucial if you are trying to build a strong relationship with Astarion, whether for friendship or romance. However, it is important to note that other companions, particularly those with a more moral or lawful alignment, may disapprove of this action.
Step-by-step, here is how you can let Astarion kill Gandrel. First, ensure that Astarion is in your party when you approach Gandrel. This is important because if Astarion is not present, you will not have the option to let him confront the hunter. When Gandrel asks about Astarion, choose dialogue options that reveal Astarion's presence or allow Astarion to step forward. Once Astarion confronts Gandrel, he will express his desire to kill the hunter. At this point, you can choose to support Astarion by letting him kill Gandrel. The combat will be relatively straightforward, as Gandrel is alone and not particularly powerful. After the fight, Astarion will express his satisfaction, and his approval of you will increase.
There are several important tips and considerations to keep in mind when making this decision. First, consider the moral implications of allowing Astarion to kill Gandrel. While it may strengthen your bond with Astarion, it could also alienate other companions who value justice and mercy. Additionally, killing Gandrel may have long-term consequences for the story, as the Gur are a significant group in the game's lore, and their questline may be affected by this action. If you are playing a character with a good or lawful alignment, you may want to think carefully before allowing this act of violence.
Common mistakes to avoid include not having Astarion in your party when you encounter Gandrel. If Astarion is not present, you will not have the option to let him kill the hunter, and the encounter will play out differently. Another mistake is failing to consider the approval ratings of other companions. While Astarion may approve of your decision, other party members may disapprove, which could affect their loyalty and willingness to support you in future quests.
Advanced techniques or optimizations involve using this decision to further your relationship with Astarion. If you are pursuing a romance with him, allowing him to kill Gandrel can be a significant step in gaining his trust and affection. Additionally, if you are playing a character with a more chaotic or evil alignment, this decision can align with your character's motivations and provide a satisfying role-playing experience.
In terms of related D&D rules and mechanics, this encounter reflects the alignment system and the concept of player choice. Astarion, as a vampire spawn, is inherently tied to themes of survival, revenge, and moral ambiguity. Allowing him to kill Gandrel is a decision that aligns with his chaotic and self-serving nature, while stopping him would reflect a more lawful or good-aligned approach. The approval system in Baldur's Gate 3 is a direct implementation of the D&D mechanics that govern relationships and character development.
Specific examples and scenarios include the potential impact on future interactions with the Gur. If you let Astarion kill Gandrel, you may encounter other Gur later in the game who are hostile towards you due to your actions. This can lead to additional combat encounters and story developments that are shaped by your earlier decision. Conversely, if you spare Gandrel, he may reappear later in the game with information or assistance that could benefit your party.
In conclusion, letting Astarion kill the Gur hunter Gandrel in Baldur's Gate 3 is a decision that has significant consequences for your relationship with Astarion and the overall story. It involves careful consideration of the approval system, the moral implications of your actions, and the potential long-term effects on the game's narrative. By following the steps outlined above and keeping these tips and considerations in mind, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your character's motivations and goals.