What are the consequences of letting Karlach die in Baldur's Gate 3?

Letting Karlach die in Baldur's Gate 3 has significant consequences, both in terms of gameplay and narrative. Karlach is a unique companion with a compelling backstory tied to the infernal and the Blood War, and her presence in your party can influence many aspects of the game. If she dies, you lose access to her abilities, her personal questline, and any potential romance or deep relationship development. HereÔÇÖs a detailed breakdown of what happens and how it affects your playthrough.

First, letÔÇÖs discuss the mechanics of KarlachÔÇÖs death. Karlach can die in several ways, such as during combat, through story choices, or by failing certain checks in her personal questline. If she dies in combat, you have the option to revive her using a Scroll of Revivify or by visiting Withers at your camp. However, if her death is tied to a story decision or quest failure, she may be permanently lost. For example, if you side with the Paladins of Tyr against her in Act 1, she will be killed, and you cannot bring her back. Similarly, if you fail to resolve her infernal engine issue in Act 2, she may die as a result of her condition.

The consequences of KarlachÔÇÖs death are multifaceted. From a gameplay perspective, losing her means losing a powerful Barbarian companion. Karlach excels in melee combat, with high damage output and durability, making her a valuable asset in tough battles. Without her, you may need to adjust your party composition, potentially relying on other melee-focused characters like LaeÔÇÖzel or a custom-built Fighter. This can affect your combat strategies, especially in encounters where her rage abilities and tanking capabilities are crucial.

Narratively, KarlachÔÇÖs death impacts the story and your relationships with other companions. Her personal questline, which involves her infernal engine and her desire for revenge against Zariel, is cut short. This means you miss out on unique dialogue, story revelations, and potential rewards tied to her quest. Additionally, other companions may react negatively to her death, especially if they had a positive relationship with her. For example, Wyll, who has a connection to Karlach through his own infernal pact, may express grief or anger, potentially affecting his approval of your actions.

There are also long-term consequences to consider. KarlachÔÇÖs survival can influence certain story outcomes in later acts, particularly in relation to the Blood War and the infernal forces at play. If she dies, these narrative threads may resolve differently, potentially leading to less favorable outcomes or missed opportunities for alliances. For instance, her knowledge of the infernal and her personal vendetta against Zariel could have provided valuable insights or advantages in dealing with devils and demons later in the game.

To avoid KarlachÔÇÖs death, itÔÇÖs important to make careful choices during her personal questline. In Act 1, you must side with her against the Paladins of Tyr, as they are hunting her under false pretenses. This requires passing certain dialogue checks or defeating the Paladins in combat. In Act 2, you need to find a way to stabilize her infernal engine, which involves seeking out Dammon, the tiefling blacksmith, and providing him with infernal iron. Failing to do so can result in her death. Additionally, keeping her alive in combat requires strategic planning, such as positioning her effectively, using her rage abilities wisely, and ensuring she has adequate healing and support.

Common mistakes to avoid include neglecting her personal questline, failing to gather infernal iron, or making choices that alienate her. ItÔÇÖs also important to manage her health in combat, as her aggressive playstyle can sometimes leave her vulnerable. Advanced techniques for optimizing her performance include equipping her with powerful weapons and armor, using her rage to mitigate damage, and coordinating her attacks with other party members to maximize damage output.

In terms of D&D 5E rules, KarlachÔÇÖs abilities are based on the Barbarian class, with features like Rage, Unarmored Defense, and Reckless Attack. Understanding these mechanics can help you use her effectively in combat. For example, Rage grants her resistance to physical damage and bonus damage on melee attacks, making her a durable and powerful frontline fighter. Unarmored Defense allows her to have a high AC without wearing heavy armor, and Reckless Attack gives her advantage on attack rolls at the cost of giving enemies advantage against her.

In summary, letting Karlach die in Baldur's Gate 3 has significant consequences for both gameplay and story. To keep her alive, you must make careful choices, complete her personal questline, and use her effectively in combat. Her survival can provide valuable benefits, including powerful combat abilities, unique story outcomes, and deeper relationships with other companions. By understanding the mechanics and strategies involved, you can ensure that Karlach remains a vital part of your party throughout the game.