How do I increase Shadowheart's approval in Baldur's Gate 3?

Increasing Shadowheart's approval in Baldur's Gate 3 involves understanding her personality, values, and the mechanics of the approval system. Shadowheart is a cleric of Shar, the goddess of darkness and loss, which heavily influences her worldview and how she reacts to your choices. She tends to favor pragmatism, secrecy, and a certain level of ruthlessness, but she also values loyalty and trust. To gain her approval, you need to align your actions and dialogue choices with these traits.

The approval system in Baldur's Gate 3 is based on how your decisions and actions resonate with each companion. When you make choices that a companion agrees with, their approval of you increases. Conversely, if you make choices they dislike, their approval decreases. Approval is tracked on a hidden scale, and significant changes in approval can unlock new dialogue options, personal quests, and even romance opportunities. For Shadowheart, gaining her approval requires a mix of strategic dialogue choices, story decisions, and combat tactics.

To start increasing Shadowheart's approval, focus on dialogue choices that reflect her values. For example, when interacting with other characters, choose options that prioritize secrecy, practicality, and a willingness to make tough decisions. In the early game, during the encounter with the Mind Flayer pod on the Nautiloid, choosing to investigate the pod and showing curiosity about its contents can earn you some approval from Shadowheart. Similarly, when dealing with the Tieflings and the Druids in the Emerald Grove, siding with the Druids or making decisions that avoid unnecessary conflict can also earn her approval.

Another key moment is during the encounter with the Goblins at the Goblin Camp. Shadowheart appreciates a cautious and strategic approach. For instance, if you choose to infiltrate the camp rather than attack head-on, she will approve. Additionally, when dealing with the leaders of the Goblin Camp, showing a willingness to deceive or manipulate them can also earn her approval. However, be careful not to be overly cruel or chaotic, as Shadowheart values a certain level of restraint and pragmatism.

Combat tactics can also influence Shadowheart's approval. She is a cleric, so she appreciates when you use healing and support spells effectively. In combat, prioritize keeping your party alive and using spells like Healing Word or Cure Wounds to support your allies. Shadowheart also has a strong connection to her deity, Shar, so using her divine abilities in combat can sometimes trigger approval gains. For example, using her Channel Divinity: Turn Undead ability against undead enemies can earn her approval.

One common mistake to avoid is being too altruistic or self-sacrificing. While Shadowheart values loyalty, she does not appreciate unnecessary risks or acts of pure selflessness. For example, if you choose to save a stranger at great personal cost, she may disapprove. Instead, focus on choices that benefit the group or align with her pragmatic worldview. Another mistake is being too open or trusting with strangers. Shadowheart values secrecy and caution, so revealing too much information or trusting others too quickly can lead to disapproval.

Advanced techniques for increasing Shadowheart's approval include leveraging her personal quest and backstory. As you progress through the game, you will learn more about her connection to Shar and her past. Engaging with her personal quest and making choices that align with her goals can significantly boost her approval. For example, when you encounter the Nightsong, a key element of her quest, making decisions that support her mission will earn her approval. Additionally, during her personal quest, showing understanding and empathy for her struggles can deepen your bond.

In terms of D&D 5E rules, Shadowheart's approval system is influenced by her alignment and class. As a cleric of Shar, she leans towards a neutral or evil alignment, which means she values actions that benefit herself or her deity over pure altruism. Understanding her alignment can help you predict how she will react to certain choices. For example, in D&D 5E, a neutral character might prioritize balance and practicality, while an evil character might prioritize personal gain. Shadowheart's approval system reflects these traits, so aligning your choices with her alignment can help you gain her approval.

Specific examples of gaining Shadowheart's approval include the encounter with the Githyanki patrol. If you choose to avoid conflict and use diplomacy, Shadowheart will approve. Similarly, during the encounter with the Hag in the Sunlit Wetlands, making choices that prioritize survival and practicality over morality can earn her approval. Another example is during the party at the Druid Grove. If you choose to share a drink with her and engage in meaningful conversation, you can increase her approval.

In summary, increasing Shadowheart's approval in Baldur's Gate 3 requires a combination of strategic dialogue choices, story decisions, and combat tactics. Focus on aligning your actions with her values of secrecy, pragmatism, and loyalty. Avoid being overly altruistic or trusting, and engage with her personal quest to deepen your bond. By understanding her personality and the mechanics of the approval system, you can build a strong relationship with Shadowheart and unlock new opportunities in the game.