What are the best dialogue choices to increase Karlach's approval in Baldur's Gate 3?

Increasing Karlach's approval in Baldur's Gate 3 involves understanding her personality, values, and the types of decisions she respects. Karlach is a tiefling barbarian with a strong sense of justice, loyalty, and a disdain for cruelty or manipulation. She appreciates boldness, honesty, and acts of kindness, especially towards those who are oppressed or in need. To maximize her approval, you need to align your dialogue choices and actions with these traits.

First, let's discuss the mechanics of approval. Approval in Baldur's Gate 3 is a hidden numerical value that increases or decreases based on your choices and actions. Each companion has their own approval rating, which influences their loyalty, dialogue options, and potential for romance. Karlach's approval is particularly tied to how you treat others, especially the downtrodden, and how you handle conflict. High approval can unlock unique dialogue, deepen your relationship, and even lead to romantic opportunities.

To increase Karlach's approval, focus on the following strategies. During conversations, choose options that demonstrate courage, fairness, and a willingness to help others. For example, when encountering the tiefling refugees in the Druid Grove, siding with them and offering assistance will earn Karlach's respect. She also approves of standing up to bullies or tyrants, so when faced with situations like confronting Kagha or dealing with the goblin leaders, opt for direct and assertive responses rather than passive or manipulative ones.

In combat, Karlach appreciates bold and decisive actions. Using her in battle and letting her unleash her barbarian rage will naturally align with her personality. Additionally, making choices that prioritize the safety and well-being of innocent people, such as protecting the tieflings or saving civilians from danger, will earn her approval. Avoid actions that involve unnecessary cruelty, deception, or exploitation, as these will lower her approval.

One important tip is to pay attention to Karlach's reactions during key story moments. For instance, during the confrontation with the paladins of Tyr who are hunting her, siding with Karlach and defending her will significantly boost her approval. Similarly, when dealing with the goblin camp, choosing to fight rather than negotiate with the leaders will align with her values. These moments are critical for building her trust and respect.

Common mistakes to avoid include being overly cautious or indecisive. Karlach values boldness and decisiveness, so hesitating or choosing neutral options can lead to missed opportunities for approval. Additionally, avoid siding with oppressive or manipulative factions, such as the Absolute cult or the goblins, as this will alienate her. Be mindful of your choices in companion interactions as well. For example, if you side with Astarion in a dispute, Karlach may disapprove if it involves cruelty or selfishness.

Advanced techniques involve leveraging Karlach's personal quest to deepen your relationship. As you progress through the game, you'll learn more about her backstory and the infernal engine in her chest. Supporting her in resolving these issues, such as finding a way to stabilize the engine or seeking revenge against those who wronged her, will earn significant approval. Additionally, engaging in her personal questline and showing genuine concern for her well-being will strengthen your bond.

In terms of related D&D rules and mechanics, Karlach's approval system is influenced by her alignment and class. As a barbarian, she values strength, courage, and direct action, which are reflected in her approval triggers. Her tiefling heritage also plays a role, as she has a natural affinity for those who stand up against oppression and injustice. Understanding these aspects of her character will help you make choices that align with her values.

Specific examples of scenarios where you can increase Karlach's approval include the early interactions with the tiefling refugees, the confrontation with the paladins of Tyr, and the decisions made in the goblin camp. In each of these situations, choosing to protect the innocent, stand up to tyranny, and act with courage will earn her respect. Additionally, during camp interactions, engaging in conversations that show empathy and understanding towards her struggles will further increase her approval.

In summary, increasing Karlach's approval in Baldur's Gate 3 requires aligning your actions and dialogue choices with her values of justice, loyalty, and boldness. By standing up for the oppressed, making decisive and courageous decisions, and supporting her personal quest, you can build a strong relationship with her. Avoid actions that involve cruelty or manipulation, and be mindful of her reactions during key story moments. With these strategies, you can maximize Karlach's approval and deepen your connection with her throughout the game.