What happens if I let Shadowheart become a Dark Justiciar in Baldur's Gate 3?

Allowing Shadowheart to become a Dark Justiciar in Baldur's Gate 3 is a significant story choice that impacts her character arc, your relationship with her, and the overall narrative. This path is tied to her personal quest, "The Chosen of Shar," and involves making decisions that align with her devotion to Shar, the goddess of darkness and loss. HereÔÇÖs a detailed breakdown of how to achieve this outcome, along with important considerations and strategies.

To begin, ShadowheartÔÇÖs questline revolves around her devotion to Shar and her desire to become a Dark Justiciar, a holy warrior of Shar. This path is heavily influenced by your dialogue choices and actions throughout the game. Early on, youÔÇÖll notice that Shadowheart is secretive about her past and her connection to Shar. Building trust with her is crucial, as it allows you to influence her decisions later in the story. To gain her trust, support her in conversations, avoid prying too much into her past, and make choices that align with SharÔÇÖs values, such as embracing darkness and rejecting Sel├╗ne, SharÔÇÖs rival goddess.

As you progress through Act 2, youÔÇÖll reach the Gauntlet of Shar, a key location tied to ShadowheartÔÇÖs quest. This area is filled with trials that test your devotion to Shar. Completing these trials is essential for Shadowheart to prove her worth and continue her path toward becoming a Dark Justiciar. The trials involve solving puzzles, defeating enemies, and making moral choices that reflect SharÔÇÖs teachings. For example, one trial requires you to embrace loss by sacrificing something valuable, while another tests your ability to navigate darkness and deception. Pay close attention to the themes of each trial, as they mirror SharÔÇÖs ideology.

Once you complete the trials, youÔÇÖll reach the Inner Sanctum of the Gauntlet of Shar, where Shadowheart faces a pivotal decision. Here, she must choose between embracing her destiny as a Dark Justiciar or rejecting SharÔÇÖs influence. To guide her toward becoming a Dark Justiciar, you must encourage her to stay loyal to Shar. This involves selecting dialogue options that affirm her faith and support her desire to serve Shar. For example, when she expresses doubt, reassure her that SharÔÇÖs path is the right one and that she is destined for greatness as a Dark Justiciar.

If you successfully guide Shadowheart down this path, she will undergo a transformation, fully embracing her role as a Dark Justiciar. This has significant consequences for her character and your relationship with her. She becomes more ruthless and devoted to Shar, which can lead to conflicts with other party members, especially those who oppose SharÔÇÖs ideology, such as LaeÔÇÖzel or Wyll. Additionally, her transformation affects the storyÔÇÖs ending, as her actions as a Dark Justiciar can influence the fate of key characters and the world itself.

There are several important tips and considerations to keep in mind when pursuing this path. First, ensure that Shadowheart is in your active party during the Gauntlet of Shar, as her presence is required to progress her questline. Second, pay attention to her approval rating, as a high approval score makes it easier to influence her decisions. You can increase her approval by making choices that align with SharÔÇÖs values, such as favoring secrecy, embracing darkness, and rejecting Sel├╗ne. Third, be prepared for the moral implications of this path, as ShadowheartÔÇÖs transformation into a Dark Justiciar involves embracing darker aspects of her personality and making sacrifices that may conflict with your own moral compass.

Common mistakes to avoid include failing to build trust with Shadowheart early in the game, which can make it difficult to influence her decisions later. Additionally, avoid making choices that openly oppose Shar or favor Sel├╗ne, as this can lead Shadowheart to reject her path as a Dark Justiciar. Finally, be cautious when navigating the Gauntlet of Shar, as some trials can be challenging and require careful planning and strategy.

Advanced techniques for optimizing this path include using ShadowheartÔÇÖs cleric abilities to their fullest potential during the Gauntlet of Shar. For example, her healing spells and support abilities can be invaluable in combat, while her knowledge of SharÔÇÖs teachings can help you solve puzzles and navigate the trials more efficiently. Additionally, consider equipping her with gear that enhances her abilities, such as items that boost her spellcasting or provide resistance to damage.

From a D&D rules perspective, ShadowheartÔÇÖs transformation into a Dark Justiciar reflects her alignment shift toward a more lawful or neutral evil orientation, depending on your choices. This aligns with SharÔÇÖs teachings, which emphasize order, secrecy, and the embrace of darkness. Her abilities as a cleric of Shar may also change, reflecting her new role as a Dark Justiciar and her deeper connection to SharÔÇÖs divine power.

In summary, guiding Shadowheart to become a Dark Justiciar involves building trust with her, supporting her devotion to Shar, and successfully navigating the Gauntlet of Shar. This path has significant consequences for her character, your relationship with her, and the overall story, making it a compelling choice for players who want to explore the darker aspects of BaldurÔÇÖs Gate 3ÔÇÖs narrative. By following these strategies and considerations, you can help Shadowheart achieve her destiny as a Dark Justiciar and shape the story in a unique and impactful way.